Brands:All Brands Agri-Fab Brinly-Hardy Yard Butler Landzie Corona Tools Sun Joe

Brand guide · 2 models compared · Oct 2026

Yard Butler Core Aerator: Lineup, Key Specs & How They Compare

Known for welded powder-coated steel garden tools, led by the 37-inch ID-6C manual dual-hollow-tine lawn coring aerator.

Quick verdict

Best for: Classic dual-tine ID-6C manual plug extraction. Focus: All-Steel Manual Coring Aerator. Top Yard Butler model in our catalog: Yard Butler ID-6C Manual Lawn Coring Aerator (37-Inch All-Steel Dual Hollow-Tine Plug Extractor).

See the lineup ↓Open compare tool

Which Yard Butler should you buy?

Hard-Packed Clay Spots & Budget Manual CoringYard Butler ID-6C Manual Lawn Coring Aerator (37-Inch All-Steel Dual Hollow-Tine Plug Extractor)Dual-Tine Manual Core Aerator · Value Manual

Check price on Amazon

Keeping Soil Plugs Off Patios, Pool Decks & WalkwaysManual 4-Tine Lawn Coring Aerator with Built-In Soil Core Catcher Tray & Cleaning RodManual Aerator w/ Core Tray · Clean-Yard Manual

Check price on Amazon

Yard Butler specs, side by side

Pick	Best for	Tine Type & Count	Working Width / Height	Ballast Capacity / Ejection	Hitch / Build Material	Listing
Value ManualYard ButlerYard Butler ID-6C (2-Tine)	Hard-Packed Clay Spots & Budget Manual Coring	2 tapered hollow steel coring tubes (3.5" tube length; ~2"–2.5" plug)	Dual-tine foot bar · 37-inch overall height	Concentrated 2-tine foot pressure · Open top-port ejection	100% welded powder-coated tubular steel (no loose bolts)	Check price on Amazon
Clean-Yard ManualDolibest4-Tine Core-Catcher Aerator	Keeping Soil Plugs Off Patios, Pool Decks & Walkways	4 stainless steel hollow coring tines (3.5" tine length)	4-tine footplate w/ integrated core catcher tray · 38" height	Top ejection directly into built-in collection tray	Stainless steel tines + steel shaft + included clearing rod	Check price on Amazon

Every Yard Butler model, ranked

Yard ButlerValue ManualBest for: Hard-Packed Clay Spots & Budget Manual Coring

Yard Butler ID-6C Manual Lawn Coring Aerator (37-Inch All-Steel Dual Hollow-Tine Plug Extractor)

Because all of your foot weight concentrates onto two hollow tines instead of three or four, the Yard Butler ID-6C penetrates dense clay easier than wide multi-tine forks.

Tine Type & Count2 tapered hollow steel coring tubes (3.5" tube length; ~2"–2.5" plug)

Working Width / HeightDual-tine foot bar · 37-inch overall height

Ballast Capacity / EjectionConcentrated 2-tine foot pressure · Open top-port ejection

Hitch / Build Material100% welded powder-coated tubular steel (no loose bolts)

Watch out for: At 37 inches tall, users over 6 feet tall will bend slightly more than with the 42-inch Landzie.

Check price on AmazonSee live price & delivery

Compare side by side

DolibestClean-Yard ManualBest for: Keeping Soil Plugs Off Patios, Pool Decks & Walkways

Manual 4-Tine Lawn Coring Aerator with Built-In Soil Core Catcher Tray & Cleaning Rod

Built-in stainless steel collection tray catches ejected soil cores as you step so you can dump them into a bucket or compost bin instead of leaving mud plugs on the grass.

Tine Type & Count4 stainless steel hollow coring tines (3.5" tine length)

Working Width / Height4-tine footplate w/ integrated core catcher tray · 38" height

Ballast Capacity / EjectionTop ejection directly into built-in collection tray

Hitch / Build MaterialStainless steel tines + steel shaft + included clearing rod

Watch out for: Spreading foot force across 4 tines means you must aerate when soil is moist; too hard to push into bone-dry clay.

Check price on AmazonSee live price & delivery

Compare side by side

Check on any Yard Butler listing

✓The exact model, size or pack on the listing (ASIN) matches the one in our table.
✓Tine Type & Count: confirm it on the listing before you buy.
✓Working Width / Height: confirm it on the listing before you buy.
✓Ballast Capacity / Ejection: confirm it on the listing before you buy.
✓Hitch / Build Material: confirm it on the listing before you buy.

About Yard Butler

Known for welded powder-coated steel garden tools, led by the 37-inch ID-6C manual dual-hollow-tine lawn coring aerator.

CoreAerator.com is independent and not affiliated with or endorsed by Yard Butler. Trademarks belong to their owners.

Yard Butler vs…

Yard Butler vs Agri-Fab→Yard Butler vs Brinly-Hardy→Yard Butler vs Landzie→Yard Butler vs Corona Tools→Open the compare tool →

Yard Butler FAQ

Who is Yard Butler best for?

Known for welded powder-coated steel garden tools, led by the 37-inch ID-6C manual dual-hollow-tine lawn coring aerator. Best for: Classic dual-tine ID-6C manual plug extraction.

Is CoreAerator.com affiliated with Yard Butler?

No. CoreAerator.com is independent, Yard Butler doesn’t pay for placement, and all brand names and trademarks belong to their owners.

What is the difference between a core aerator and a spike aerator?

A hollow-tine core aerator (also called a plug aerator) extracts finger-sized cylinders of soil and deposits them on top of the lawn, creating open channels that let compacted soil expand, breathe, and absorb water. A solid-spike aerator (or aerator shoes) merely pokes holes by pushing soil sideways and downward, which can actually tighten compacted clay around each hole.

Best Yard Butler in our catalog

Yard Butler ID-6C Manual Lawn Coring Aerator (37-Inch All-Steel Dual Hollow-Tine Plug Extractor)

Check price on Amazon